Why do you need a mentor? Well, the truth is you can probably get by without one, but you'll potentially waste a lot of time, money, tears, and sweat and get fewer rewards. A mentor is someone who offers really great advice, which you can decide to follow or not. A mentor is not a best friend or a parent or a lover. A mentor is more impartial, and they know a lot more about the professional world that you're studying than your family and friends. Even if your mom is a doctor and you want to become one too, it's still a good idea to find someone else to mentor you along the way. There's a reason they don't let doctors operate on their own children, right?
I don't think that I was very good as a student about finding mentors. I was too shy, perhaps, or too afraid to invade my professors' personal space. I remember once going into a favorite professor's office to ask a question and finding her munching on a jelly doughnut. I had a really strange sort of shock. I think I was actually surprised that this brilliant lecturer ate actual, normal, everyday food like jelly doughnuts. I guess I expected her to be living off of red wine and cheese or something. Who knows.
The point of the story is this: professors are actually real people. You will like some of them and you will dislike others. They won't all like you, either. No biggie. Try to find a mentor you like who seems to like you too, but keep the relationship professional. A mentor does not ask you to walk his dog or grade his papers (unless you are a paid assistant). Generally, grabbing a drink with your mentor at the local pub only happens in graduate school (or in Britain...).
You might want to think about looking for a mentor as a combination of two things. You want an intellectual mentor, someone who can help you make good decisions about what classes to take, what your major will be, and the like. This is the person that you go to first when asking for a letter of recommendation. The second thing you might want in a mentor is a more supportive, personal relationship, particularly if you are new to college.
If you can't find both of these in one person, then split the "mentor" role into two faculty members. You might have a solid professional relationship with a professor in your field of study, but a more personal mentor who is a counselor or, as often happens, some other professor that you just happened to meet along the way. Splitting up the role is fine, as long as you're clear about what types of support and advice both can give you, and as long as you don't become too dependent on either person. Your English prof really can't give you decent advice about graduate school in Sociology, so don't expect it.
Whatever types of mentor you find, remember that it is still your life, and the decisions are yours--not your mentor's! I often have students asking me what they should do in school and life, and I sometimes feel that they want me to create a twenty year plan for their lives--first you will finish school, then go to graduate school where you will meet the man of your dreams, then get a prestigious job as a...... If only they knew that at their age I barely had a one year plan! Ask for advice, and if you need more than advice, remember that almost all colleges and universities offer free counseling services and career counseling to help you with some of those BIG life decisions.
Don't be afraid, like I was as a young student, to ask for help from someone outside your family. Some college professors are actually in the business because they like to help young people. The rest of us are here for the fantastic money....
Monday, November 16, 2009
Monday, November 9, 2009
Being Late
This semester I am taking my daughter to elementary school in the mornings, and I had an epiphany the other day when I realized that there are about ten parents in the school who bring their kids to school late almost every day. Inevitably, there's one family who is hurrying along, clearly feeling bad about being late. That's a revolving group of people, never the same faces twice. But there is a core group of late families who seem completely unfazed by their lateness. Mom usually has a coffee from the local java shop in hand, and they stroll across the street, happily saying "hi" to those of us who are already leaving, having left our wonderkids in the loving care of their teachers. I am astounded at these parents and their lack of respect for the school, the teachers, and their own children--not to mention all the other kids who get there on time whose morning are interrupted by teachers who have to get the latercomers settled. I'm saddened by the fact that their otherwise charming children are growing up trained to be latercomers who will, and here's the honest truth, be slightly discriminated against in school and in the workplace if they continue to follow their parents' example.
So, college students, here's the brutal truth: being habitually late WILL hurt you in life. Your parents did a disservice to you to teach you otherwise. If this is their only major fault, forgive them and move on. Nobody's perfect. But believe me, being late regularly will cost you in life and in school. Think about it this way: given the choice between a late job applicant and one on time, who would you hire? Most employers won't even give you a second look if you arrive late.
You may think that your professors don't care about your tardiness, or you may think it doesn't matter because you aren't losing any points toward your end-of-term grade. But there are bunch of intangible things you are losing--like letters of recommendation, offers of scholarships, and all the news and advice that most profs. actually give in the first couple of minutes. Those minutes before class starts are the times when you can get to know your profs. in a small class, and you should consider them just as important as the lectures.
Everyone's late once in awhile, even profs, and we don't hold this against you at all. But many profs. I know don't take very seriously those students who make a habit of it.
It's not too late to change...that's what college is for, after all!
So, college students, here's the brutal truth: being habitually late WILL hurt you in life. Your parents did a disservice to you to teach you otherwise. If this is their only major fault, forgive them and move on. Nobody's perfect. But believe me, being late regularly will cost you in life and in school. Think about it this way: given the choice between a late job applicant and one on time, who would you hire? Most employers won't even give you a second look if you arrive late.
You may think that your professors don't care about your tardiness, or you may think it doesn't matter because you aren't losing any points toward your end-of-term grade. But there are bunch of intangible things you are losing--like letters of recommendation, offers of scholarships, and all the news and advice that most profs. actually give in the first couple of minutes. Those minutes before class starts are the times when you can get to know your profs. in a small class, and you should consider them just as important as the lectures.
Everyone's late once in awhile, even profs, and we don't hold this against you at all. But many profs. I know don't take very seriously those students who make a habit of it.
It's not too late to change...that's what college is for, after all!
Wednesday, November 4, 2009
How to Get Great Letters of Recommendation
First of all, the truth: everyone hates to ask for letters of reference or recommendation. Even tenured professors have to ask their colleagues (coworkers) for them from time to time, and we hate it. However, it's a necessary evil, and a good letter of recommendation will be essential for you. If you're reading this post, it's probably because you need a recommendation NOW. Hopefully you've already laid some groundwork, but if not, don't worry. You'll figure it out.
Step One: Ask the right person. Usually this means the former professor or boss who really knows you well. Note that I said "former" professor. Generally, it's not a good idea to ask a current professor for a letter, unless it's someone you have taken classes with before, or unless it's near the end of the semester and you have done really well in the class. If you can, ask a professor in the field of study that you intend to pursue. So if you're going for a math scholarship, ask a math prof. Some students spend a lot of time trying to get "famous" profs to write them letters. Think about this, because it can backfire. Having read a lot of applications over the years, I can almost quote a certain "famous" professor's letters because he writes the same letter for everyone. It becomes meaningless. A really personal letter by some regular professor who knows you well will probably help you more. (If you don't know any professors well, then ask youself why not. If you're new to college, that's okay--ask the person who you know or like best, as you're probably just applying for smaller things at that point anyway. If you're been around awhile and no professor would recognize you by name, then you need to change your approach to college.)
Step Two: How to ask. Be organized and polite. Ask the professor for the letter at least a month in advance of the deadline. First, ask if they can do it by visiting them personally in office hours or after class. Explain what the letter is for and tell them the due date. When they say "yes," tell them that you will give them all the necessary forms and information at your next class. If they say no or maybe, don't ask them again. For whatever reason, this means they don't feel comfortable writing you a letter. You DON'T want their letter, as it will be lukewarm at best. Get over it and move on to the next person on your list.
When you give them the form, if there is one, make sure that you have read it carefully and all the areas you are supposed to fill out are neatly completed. Include an unofficial copy of your transcript and a copy of your resume or CV, if you have put one together already. Give them a stamped, addressed envelope, if possible. Also, type out a note to them thanking them for agreeing to write you a letter and reminding them of the due date. It is perfectly acceptable to give them a date a bit earlier than the actual due date to accomodate mail delays.
Step Three: Remind them. Some of your professors will write the letter the day you give it to them, and it'll be over. The rest of us will put it in a "to do" stack on our desks and hopefully not forget it. Your job is to politely remind the prof who is writing your letter. A great way to do this is to send him or her a thank you note for writing the letter a couple of days before it's due. Tricky, but effective. They think, "Oh yes, I have to do that," and then they do it. If you choose another method of politely reminding them, make sure you send a thank you note anyway.
A special word to graduate school applicants: Applying to grad school is a whole time-consuming, heart wrenching enterprise. You should be getting letters from professors who know you extremely well, and with whom you should have discussed at some length your grad school options. Early in the term before applications are due, make an appointment to see several of your professors in your chosen field(s) of study to discuss graduate school options. Ask them to help you compile a list of schools to apply to, and ask them for advice about writing samples, letters, and other requirements. Always apply to a variety of grad schools, as entrance is determined by a variety of factors, not just your brilliance. More on that in future posts...
Step One: Ask the right person. Usually this means the former professor or boss who really knows you well. Note that I said "former" professor. Generally, it's not a good idea to ask a current professor for a letter, unless it's someone you have taken classes with before, or unless it's near the end of the semester and you have done really well in the class. If you can, ask a professor in the field of study that you intend to pursue. So if you're going for a math scholarship, ask a math prof. Some students spend a lot of time trying to get "famous" profs to write them letters. Think about this, because it can backfire. Having read a lot of applications over the years, I can almost quote a certain "famous" professor's letters because he writes the same letter for everyone. It becomes meaningless. A really personal letter by some regular professor who knows you well will probably help you more. (If you don't know any professors well, then ask youself why not. If you're new to college, that's okay--ask the person who you know or like best, as you're probably just applying for smaller things at that point anyway. If you're been around awhile and no professor would recognize you by name, then you need to change your approach to college.)
Step Two: How to ask. Be organized and polite. Ask the professor for the letter at least a month in advance of the deadline. First, ask if they can do it by visiting them personally in office hours or after class. Explain what the letter is for and tell them the due date. When they say "yes," tell them that you will give them all the necessary forms and information at your next class. If they say no or maybe, don't ask them again. For whatever reason, this means they don't feel comfortable writing you a letter. You DON'T want their letter, as it will be lukewarm at best. Get over it and move on to the next person on your list.
When you give them the form, if there is one, make sure that you have read it carefully and all the areas you are supposed to fill out are neatly completed. Include an unofficial copy of your transcript and a copy of your resume or CV, if you have put one together already. Give them a stamped, addressed envelope, if possible. Also, type out a note to them thanking them for agreeing to write you a letter and reminding them of the due date. It is perfectly acceptable to give them a date a bit earlier than the actual due date to accomodate mail delays.
Step Three: Remind them. Some of your professors will write the letter the day you give it to them, and it'll be over. The rest of us will put it in a "to do" stack on our desks and hopefully not forget it. Your job is to politely remind the prof who is writing your letter. A great way to do this is to send him or her a thank you note for writing the letter a couple of days before it's due. Tricky, but effective. They think, "Oh yes, I have to do that," and then they do it. If you choose another method of politely reminding them, make sure you send a thank you note anyway.
A special word to graduate school applicants: Applying to grad school is a whole time-consuming, heart wrenching enterprise. You should be getting letters from professors who know you extremely well, and with whom you should have discussed at some length your grad school options. Early in the term before applications are due, make an appointment to see several of your professors in your chosen field(s) of study to discuss graduate school options. Ask them to help you compile a list of schools to apply to, and ask them for advice about writing samples, letters, and other requirements. Always apply to a variety of grad schools, as entrance is determined by a variety of factors, not just your brilliance. More on that in future posts...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)